Sample of Formative Assessment: 12 Examples for Writing

Sample of Formative Assessment: 12 Examples for Writing

A formative assessment is any short, low-stakes check that shows you what students understand while learning is still happening. A minute paper, an exit ticket, a peer-reviewed draft and a one-paragraph explanation in a student’s own words are all samples. Below you will find twelve of them, with the exact prompt, what to look for and what to do next. Writing gets extra attention, because a few written sentences show thinking better than almost any other quick check.

WritinglabMake Writing Feedback EasierWriting Lab helps teachers assess student writing and provide actionable feedback, while helping students improve their writing skills.Explore Writing Lab

TL;DR

  • Formative assessment is ongoing, low-stakes evidence gathered during learning so teachers and students can adjust. It is usually not graded.
  • Good samples are short: exit tickets, minute papers, application cards, own-words explanations, and draft-plus-rubric self-checks.
  • For writing, feedback works best when students can apply it right away. Detailed comments tend to do more good without a grade attached.
  • A check only counts if you act on it: reteach, regroup, give feedback or move on within a day or two.
  • IELTS and TOEFL candidates can run the same checks on themselves to decide what to practice next.

Table of Contents

What makes an assessment formative

The U.S. Department of Education’s 2023 guide describes formative assessment as ongoing feedback during learning that is low-stakes, not typically graded, and used to adjust instruction in real time. A summative assessment, by contrast, comes at the end of an instructional period to judge and summarize what was achieved.

Indiana University’s teaching center draws the same line in practical terms: formative work is focused, usually in class, low-stakes and aimed at improving a specific skill. Summative work is usually graded and broader. The National Foundation for Educational Research adds that formative assessment often starts diagnostically, finding existing knowledge and gaps, then shows whether teaching should be amended to reinforce or extend learning.

A peer-reviewed framework in CBE Life Sciences Education frames it as a loop. A prompt makes student thinking visible, the evidence informs teacher and learner, and each adapts: the teacher changes the lesson, the student changes how they study or asks for help.

Prompt, evidence, and instructional feedback loop

A quick test: if the result will change what happens in tomorrow’s lesson or in the student’s next draft, it is formative. If it only goes in a gradebook, it is not.

Quick samples for any subject

These work in a science class, a history class or an English class. Each takes under ten minutes.

1. Exit ticket

Sample prompt: “Write one thing you can now do that you could not do at the start of class, and one question you still have.”

The Department of Education guide describes exit tickets as brief checkpoints that can use short-answer, multiple-choice or true/false questions. Sort the cards into three piles: got it, almost, lost. That sorting is the whole analysis.

2. Minute paper

Sample prompt: “In one minute, write the most important point from today and the least clear point.”

The University of Wisconsin-La Crosse teaching guide suggests scanning responses for patterns, then clarifying or reteaching before or during the next class. If six students name the same muddy point, that is your opening five minutes tomorrow.

3. Short quiz with no grade

Three to five questions at the start of class on yesterday’s material. The same UW-La Crosse guide treats brief retrieval activities as doing two jobs: they show you misconceptions and they strengthen memory for the student. Keep the score private or ungraded so students answer honestly.

4. Think-pair-share

Pose a question, give students a minute to think, a minute to talk to a neighbor, then call on a few pairs. The University of Illinois Chicago lists it alongside polling, concept maps, discussion boards and muddiest-point prompts. Walk the room and listen. What you overhear is evidence.

5. Observation checklist

Pick three or four behaviors tied to the objective, such as “cites evidence from the text” or “revises a topic sentence.” Mark them as you circulate. It takes no student time and gives you data on individuals.

Samples built for writing

Writing is where formative assessment pays off most, because you see the thinking and the language together. Research backs this up. A meta-analysis by Graham, Hebert and Harris of grades 1 to 8 found that formative feedback improved writing quality. The average weighted effect sizes were 0.87 for adult feedback, 0.58 for peer feedback, 0.62 for self-feedback and 0.38 for computer feedback. Every source helped, and teacher feedback helped most.

Writing feedback effect sizes by source

6. Explain it in your own words

Sample prompt: “In three to five sentences, explain photosynthesis to a friend who missed class.”

UW-La Crosse suggests sorting these by conceptual accuracy, use of examples and use of course material. The categories show you whether students have shallow recall or real understanding.

7. Application card

Sample prompt: “Write one real-world situation where this principle applies, and say why it fits.”

The teacher sorts cards by how appropriate the application is, then walks the class through a few chosen examples, good and weak. Students see the standard by comparing.

8. One-minute essay or journal entry

UIC includes one-minute essays, three-minute reflections and journals among its formative options. For an English class, the prompt might be: “What is the main claim of your draft, and what is your strongest piece of evidence?” A student who cannot answer in two sentences has a structure problem you can fix before the full essay is due.

9. Draft, rubric self-check, teacher comment

UIC describes a sequence worth copying:

  1. Students submit a written assignment with a rubric-based self-assessment.
  2. You respond with feedback.
  3. Students review peers’ work using the same rubric.
  4. Students revise an earlier piece and reflect on what they learned.

The rubric does double duty. It tells students what good looks like before you comment, so your feedback can be shorter.

10. Peer review with a narrow focus

Do not ask peers to “give feedback.” Ask them to do one job: underline the thesis, mark where evidence is missing, or circle sentences that confuse them. A narrow task produces usable comments and keeps the peer’s role low-stakes.

11. Paragraph rewrite

Sample prompt: “Here is your body paragraph with my comment. Rewrite it in 10 minutes and note what you changed.”

The note matters. A realist review of feedback research by Ajjawi and colleagues reported that students who explained how they had addressed feedback, or used checklists and reflective forms, performed better later in the studies reviewed.

12. Reflection log

After each draft, students write three lines: what feedback I got, what I will do about it, what I will check next time. Over a term, the log shows whether the same problem keeps coming back.

A worked example: formative assessment in a writing unit

Imagine a ninth-grade unit on argumentative paragraphs over three weeks.

Day Check What you learn Next move
1 Exit ticket: “State a claim about school start times in one sentence” Who can write a debatable claim Model three weak claims and fix them together
4 Application card: “Give one piece of evidence and explain why it supports your claim” Who confuses evidence with opinion Small group for the confused students
8 Draft paragraph with rubric self-check Gaps between self-rating and your rating Short comments on one criterion only
10 Peer review: underline the claim and the evidence Whether students can spot structure in others’ work Pair students who see it with those who do not
13 Revision with change note Whether feedback was understood and used Move on or reteach
15 Summative essay Final achievement Graded

Nothing in the first five rows is graded, yet by the sixth you know what to expect. That is the point of formative work.

What good formative writing feedback looks like

The Ajjawi review, which covered 58 relevant studies, found that feedback on open-ended writing works better when it comes with scaffolded tasks, dialogue, action plans and sequenced tasks that support students’ sense of relatedness, competence and autonomy. Detailed comments were linked to better scores on later essays and worked best without grades or praise attached.

In practice:

  • Name one issue and one next step. “Your second paragraph makes a claim but gives no evidence. Add one example from the reading” beats five scattered margin notes.
  • Hold back the grade. A number can end the conversation. Students stop reading the comments.
  • Give a chance to use it. Feedback is more usable when it can be applied directly to subsequent work, so build a revision step into the schedule.
  • Ask for an action plan. One sentence from the student: “Next draft I will…”

Acting on the results

Collecting evidence is the easy half. The Australian Education Research Organisation’s formative assessment practice guide frames good practice as eliciting evidence, interpreting it against the intended learning, and taking responsive action. The American Psychological Association advises keeping the interval between assessment and intervention short.

A simple decision rule after any check:

  • Most of the class got it: move on, and pull a small group for the few who did not.
  • About half got it: reteach in a different way, with a new example, then check again briefly.
  • Most of the class missed it: the instruction needs to change, not the students. Reteach the whole class.
  • Errors cluster on one criterion: give feedback on that criterion only.

In language classes, tracking individual gaps over many checks gets heavy. Guides on real-time feedback for language students show how performance reports and targeted practice can follow from what a teacher sees in class.

Using formative checks for IELTS and TOEFL writing

Test candidates can run the same loop on their own. Write a timed response, check it against the published scoring criteria for your test, pick one weakness, fix it in a rewrite, and repeat. Do not try to fix everything at once. Treat each practice essay as a diagnostic, not a verdict.

A weekly routine that works:

  1. Monday: write one timed essay from a fresh question. Practice questions are easy to produce with an IELTS question generator.
  2. Tuesday: score yourself against the criteria, then get outside feedback. Note the one criterion that cost you most.
  3. Wednesday: rewrite only the paragraph with the biggest problem.
  4. Thursday: read a model article and write a two-sentence summary to practice picking out main points. An IELTS essay summarizer helps you check whether your summary caught the main argument.
  5. Friday: write your reflection log: what changed, what to watch next week.

After four weeks, compare your logs. If the same criterion shows up three times, that is your study plan.

Our perspective

We build writing tools for teachers and students, and the pattern we see is that feedback is the bottleneck. Teachers know that frequent, low-stakes writing checks improve learning, but marking thirty paragraphs by hand takes an evening. So the checks get skipped, and the only writing that gets looked at is the big graded essay, when it is too late to help.

Our view is that AI should take the repetitive part of that job: a first read against a rubric, a consistent set of comments, a list of the errors that recur. The teacher then spends time on what only a teacher can do, deciding what the class needs next and talking to the student who is stuck. The research is a reminder that adult feedback had the largest effect in the meta-analysis above, so the goal is not to replace teacher judgment but to make it possible to use it more often.

For students, the same idea applies. A quick check against a rubric before you submit, and a rewrite after, teaches more than a score ever will.

— Sabba

Run these checks faster with Writing Lab

If you want to try these samples without the marking pile, Writing Lab offers AI essay grading, rubric generation, writing feedback, grammar checking and IELTS and TOEFL practice in one place. Teachers can generate a rubric, run a draft against it and get comments to build a revision step around. Students can practice and get feedback between lessons. There is a free tier, so you can test it on a single class set or a single essay.

Writinglab

To start with exam practice, generate an IELTS question and write your first timed response. You can also explore the rest of the tools at Writing Lab.

FAQ

What is a good sample of formative assessment?

An exit ticket is the simplest. At the end of class, students write one thing they learned and one question they still have. It takes about three minutes, requires no grading, and tells you right away what to reteach.

What is an example of formative assessment in writing?

A draft paragraph with a rubric self-check followed by a short teacher comment and a revision is a strong example. Students rate their own work against the rubric, receive one targeted comment, rewrite, and note what they changed. The same pattern works with peer review in place of teacher comments.

Should formative assessments be graded?

Usually not. The Department of Education guide describes them as low-stakes and not typically graded. Research on written feedback also suggests detailed comments work best without grades attached, because students then focus on the comment instead of the number.

How often should I use formative assessment?

As often as you can act on the results. A quick check every lesson is common, and a larger writing check every one to two weeks suits a writing unit. If you cannot respond within a day or two, the check is too big.

How is a formative test different from a summative test?

A formative test happens during learning to guide next steps, and it is low-stakes. A summative test happens at the end of a unit or course to judge what was achieved, and it is usually graded.

Sources